Recently, the Minnesota Senate approved
legislation that would create a top Minnesota tax rate of 9.7 percent for
couples on income above $250,000 and for singles on income above $141,250,
giving the state the highest top income tax rate in the nation.
What’s interesting is that state government funding can grow by 9.8% to a
total near $35 billion for all programs – this amounts to $3 billion in new
funding – without having to raise taxes. Governor Pawlenty believes this is
enough, and has promised to veto any proposals containing tax increases.
The reasoning is simple. This legislation targets the top 1 percent of
wage earners, and they already pay 24.3 percent of all state income taxes.
On average, these folks pay $87,552 per year for state and local taxes.
It’s also troublesome because the top wage earners create jobs. It will
unfairly target many small business owners because these folks file their
tax returns as individuals. According to non-partisan Minnesota House
researchers, of the 28,500 returns that would be affected by the new tax
bracket, 16,500 of them have business income reported on their individual
returns. These people are estimated to pay about $109 million of the
proposed $178 million tax increase – or about 60 percent of the total.
Common sense will tell you that many of the mom and pop store owners
being targeted by this increase are not among the “rich.” If you take
thousands of dollars of profit away from any businessman through tax hikes,
he’s going to look for ways to cut those expenses. And the easiest way to do
that is to eliminate jobs.
We all know the best way to stamp out homelessness is to have a job. And
without a solid business climate, our state will lose employment
opportunities. We saw this in 2001, when many businesses were fleeing the
state because of our taxes. The Legislature cut business taxes, and
eventually added more incentives to bring business here - like Job
Opportunity Building Zones – and the job climate turned around. If we have
the highest income tax in the nation, why would employers choose to do
business here?
Despite all of these reasons, and the Governor being on record as saying
he will not sign any bill with a tax hike, House and Senate leadership is
pressing ahead with plans to raise taxes. With five weeks left in session it
seems like a waste of time, energy, and your tax dollars to craft
legislation that is guaranteed of being vetoed.